Frat Star Friday: The Bisexual Manifesto
I asked Frat Star to re-publish a post he had written for his previous blog. It's what made me realize what a great writer he was and also, how amazing he was at explaining things..how we feel..how bi guys are. Next week, he will continue with his post on 'Bro Dating'.
So, without further adue --
The Most Important Post You'll Read All Year
My name is X, and I am twenty-one years old. I have dirty blonde hair and green eyes. I’m 6’3 and weigh 197 pounds, but I’m trying to get in better shape… not that I’m fat or anything. I’m a junior in college. My major is philosophy. I think it’s cool. Like most other college students, I drink alcohol and smoke marijuana socially. I’ve got a crew of a few good friends that I chill with at school. We typically shoot the shit about girls, sports and life in general but on Mondays we play backyard football in an intramural league. I like to think I’m pretty well liked. Overall, if you met me you’d think that I was the average college kid. As a matter of fact, if you saw me walking down fraternity row, you wouldn’t think twice about me. Maybe if you were a dude I’d met at a party you’d awkwardly tilt your head up in acknowledgement, or if you were a girl – hopefully a cute one – you might smile and say hello but otherwise I’m a small cog in the big social machine that is college.

I’ve
given you a lot of background to describe who I am because it takes a
lot to admit the skeletons in your closet, so here it goes: I’m
bisexual. Oh, you’re surprised? Yeah, I’m sure you are. I’ve cultivated
every single aspect of my personality to hide this one small fact from
civilization, even my parents. If I came out publicly my old man would
die of shame – his old army buddies wouldn’t approve – while my mom
would encourage me to buy some queer condo in a rapidly gentrifying
neighborhood so I could live with my "life partner." Screw that. What
happened to the good old college try? Isn’t college supposed to be the
time where you make mistakes, where you experience new emotions and
feelings, where you try on a bunch of new things to find out who you
really are and then you make an educated decision as to who you really
are? No, that is a lie, a goddamned lie. Maybe it’s true if you operate
as one of the cogs in the big machine and change your major from
Economics (I can still see my mom saying this: "Oh honey, it’ll be good
for your career! Think of grad school!") to something obscure like
Egyptology, Urban Planning or whatever major Brown University is
offering to their students these days. Not that I go to Brown, but I
don’t know of another school that offers stuff like Aramaic. But if you
really want to break the mold, if you really want to challenge
thousands of years of societal constructs, that’s all nonsense. Case in
point: I know a kid who experimented with a total fag who ratted him out
and now he’s a walking pariah. Frankly, I’m surprised he hasn’t been
dragged out of my dorm into the Student Union and ritually stoned by my
peers. One of my best friends is quasi-dating one of his teammates right
now at a large Southern university. Shit, if those good old boys ever
found out that two varsity players were fucking around I think they’d
ritually burn them on the Quad.
Now that I’ve explained all of that to you, I’d imagine that you’d try and console me. After all, this is the twenty first century and homosexuals are accepted in society now. But I’m not gay as far as I know. Hell, I haven’t even confirmed that I have a solid identity. I like pussy. As a matter of fact, I like pussy a lot thank you very much. I just tried something – an impulse like an itch you want to scratch – and now I’m automatically relegated to being gay. Sometimes people try things, don’t like them at first, and then love them later. Sometimes people try things, like them at first, and then hate them up later. Let me give you an example. I remember waking up really early one day when I was just a pup, it was probably like six in the morning, and I was really bored. My old man was asleep, so I started looking around the house for my mom. I don’t really remember what the hell I was trying to accomplish, but I just wanted to see her I guess. The night before my folks had a Christmas party where my dad invited a bunch of managers from work – he used to run a fancy department in downtown Baltimore before it shut down – and my folks got into a fight and I suppose he just passed out after from all the liquor he put down. I guess they were having some problems at the time, like all couples have eventually, but she offered to give me a sip of what was champagne. I just thought it was so gross, but now if you give me a nice cold brew I’ll slam that shit down like the next guy. That was an eventual progression. Just because I tried something doesn’t mean I identify with it, or that it consumes my life. It also doesn’t mean that I can’t restrain myself – I’m not a fucking alcoholic because I have self-control. Too many people don’t have enough self-control or will power these days.
So
why make a judgment call about me if I myself am not sure who I am or,
to relate back to the story, what I like. Can’t I like both? Is there
something inherently wrong, or immoral about that? Even the Catechism
(mom sent me off to college with it) says that having homosexual
feelings are not a crime, but that the act is reprehensible. Isn’t any
premarital sex reprehensible though? I’ve bagged a few girls in my time,
so haven’t I already had my fair share of mortal sins? Why is this
mortal sin worse than the others? It’s not, and it shouldn’t be. I’ve
taken myself out of communion with God while having sex in a
relationship as well as in a number of one night stands, so what makes
this one act worse than any other? If I lust after the image of a
lingerie model on a billboard, why does society seek to judge me if I
were to do the same to a man? These are the frustrating questions that I
ask myself to no avail.

You can’t explain a homosexual encounter between bisexual kids to someone who is heterosexual. Likewise, you can’t explain it to a confirmed homosexual because more often than not he was destined to be gay. Most guys who are openly gay in college fall into your typical swishy stereotype. It’s actually kind of funny in a way, because in high schools across the nation there are flaming gay kids in every drama class from California to New York who haven’t publically announced their sexuality – however obvious it may be – and these are the kids who you know are gay in college. They can’t hide behind a persona, because they can’t help themselves. It’s in their nature to act in a certain way, just like birds fly or wolves hunt. But if you take a look at a freak sexual encounter amongst two curious parties, it’s very different. Actually, it’s completely different because you aren’t going for the guy like you are for the girl; with that dude it’s all about bonding. Nowadays in television, you’ll see a whole genre of "bromance" films about how guys form a tight bond where they proclaim their love for each other. But what happens when these bonds are so strong that you can do anything together? That’s when society runs out of answers, because authentic real men aren’t supposed to make any sort of advance because that would throw off the whole heterosexual male bonding process. Men can get close to a certain level, but then the majority of the time they’ll back off because they wouldn’t have any interest in men; those guys want to solely function as your closest crew in good times and bad. But maybe you’ll bond with someone over the years, grow up with them, fight "enemy" football teams on gridirons and sweat and bleed with them. What do you do when you develop that certain level of intimacy, one that’s inherently different from that of a girl?
Short answer: you panic. You feel guilty as fuck and want to rip your guts out for being different. You look at your folks, who aren’t perfect, but see that they’re pretty happy with what they’ve got in life. You want that. You look at your girlfriend and see how dedicated she is to you. You want to give her that back. You look at your boys and see them running up and down the crease with you. You want to "defend this house" with them. For an athletic, masculine bisexual kid life is not easy especially when you’re young. Your first taste of masculinity is like opening Pandora’s Box, letting in a tide of emotions. I know exactly how to describe it too, I think. You ever taken a flight on an airplane? I took a really bad one once when the weather was shitty outside and you could barely stand up in the wind outside the terminal. You’re in this steel thing that by all common logic shouldn’t be able to move an inch let alone get up in the air, and its bouncing around like crazy while you hold onto the armrests in your seat. You pray for the flight to just end or for the plane to land, but you realize with terror that you’re just going to have to stick it out through every air pocket and every lump. You look around you and there’s a pretty mixed reaction with your fellow passengers. That businessman in the suit is just reading his copy of the Wall Street Journal minding his own business. He’s been through this before. The lady next to you, she looks very nice, is freaking out nearly as much as you are. Things are falling apart, yet very controlled. That’s what it feels like to be bisexual: organized chaos. And as every sportsman knows, from chaos comes victory. But your victories, however sweet, will always be short. Look at the Olympics: athletes train for years in order to get 30 seconds on international television and a little piece of metal on some fucked silk string.
I remember the first time I really fucked around with a dude. In lower school, I had compared with a guy but that’s like saying I held some chick’s hand. Later I jerked off once or twice with some buddies while watching softcore porn but we had the lights dimmed and mountains of pillows in between us because somehow that was "less gay." Those times were nothing in comparison to my first real experience. His name was Jack. He was two grades older, and therefore much cooler than me. We were at a house party and we both had shot-gunned a ton of brews. We hit on every piece of pussy in the room but no girl was feeling either of us that night. "Fucking sluts," we kept saying in a slurred unison, a thought that was ironic at the time given that most of the girls we knew hadn’t even given their long-term boyfriends a blowie yet.

Soon it was time to break the seal. Now if you’re a guy, regardless of your sexual orientation, you’ll know how satisfying a group piss can be. Drunk group pissing ranks up there with good shits, late-night 3-o-clock "chill seshes" and that feeling that you’re the man because that cute girl with light eyes laughs at your shitty jokes. During that bro piss I caught a glimpse of the head of his dick. It looked soft, like girl skin, and I stiffened a little bit. My pulse quickened. Sometime during that moment we crossed a boundary that society tells us we shouldn’t and we got hard. Hooking up with Jack was instinctive, like drinking, eating or sleeping. This isn’t an erotic story so I’m going to save you the details – sorry – but we did shit together. It was fun. That’s all you need to know and that’s a part of the problem: bisexual guys are quiet about their activities.
There are a lot of reasons for discretion when you’re male and bi. Part of it is that people will look at you differently. Sure, there are kids who are bi and make it work, but they tend to be cut from a different cloth than a lot of other bi kids. The discreet and quiet bisexual guys are one of the most underrepresented groups in America today. We’re the silent majority, yet no two of us are exactly alike. It’s sort of like snow: each snowflake is different but it’s still fucking snow. We view our sexuality from a "straight" standpoint – there is nothing different in between us bisexuals and our friends except that we sometimes fuck around with people of the same sex. Big damn deal. I like it that way. It’s simple. I don’t want to be "different" I just want to be true to who I am. As bisexuals, we want to keep dating girls, but we also want to get around with guys. It’s the most complicated form of sexuality because there aren’t any firm rules about sex in our own minds. We aren’t completely straight nor are we gay. Instead bi kids fall somewhere in an uncomfortable middle and that is where the criticism begins.
People
are afraid of what they don’t know. Like a little kid wondering through
the steep staircase of a dark house at night, bisexuality is scary for
people to comprehend because there is no firm definition. Even worse,
society makes broad assumptions based on individual groups. The problem
is that we aren’t a sub-set; we’re an individual brand. Being bisexual
is not like a menstruation cycle, as some people would suggest, where
I’m a "normal" kid for 29 days and then on the 30th I
turn into a "faggot." This is not a Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde situation.
Nor is it because I have a hyperactive sex drive and my promiscuity just
overflows from girls into dudes. The problem with bisexual kids is that
they value the person and they derive their sexual attraction from
their individual connection with a person. Instead of lumping our
emotional and sexual attractions together, they are entirely separate.
Our penis may lead one way and our heart may lead the other. Society
hates this. They want to tell us that we’re wrong because they don’t
understand how we work. This is the worst thing possible for young male
bisexuals, because they can’t fight back against an ingrained system. No
wonder identifying as bisexual is a terrifying prospect for most young
men.
The
straight community operates in large generalizations. The general
public expects young men to chase after young women with vigor while
acknowledging the mere existence of the homosexual community. Straight
people are unable to fully understand the homosexual community for a
variety of reasons that range from cultural differences to sexual
preference but they realize that they exist by a simple generalization:
gay people like men. There is no black and white. Like the "one-drop"
race rule of the Old South, any person who commits a homosexual act is
automatically linked as gay in the mind of most heterosexual people. The
homosexual community is even less accepting of bisexuality than the
straight community and many falsely view bisexuals as being in the
closet. Bisexuals who want to come out therefore can’t escape a torrent
of criticism from both sides of the sexual spectrum and therefore stay
deep in the closet, where it is safe emotionally, mentally and
physically.

There
is no easy way for any bisexual to come out of the closet. Like any
minority – and let me take a moment to make this crystal clear, we are
an oppressed minority – there must be a first generation to break
boundaries. We undoubtedly owe a large debt to our homosexual cousins
who first shattered the sexuality barrier in 1969 during the Stonewall
Riots. Unlike homosexuals, however, I feel that the bisexual community
has made relatively little progress. Rather than being seen as equals,
we are instead categorized in various ways: cowards, frauds, homophobes
and perverts are all words used to describe bisexuals. In 2005, the New
York Times published an article claiming that bisexuals were all simply
homosexuals in denial. There has still been no rebuttal. No wonder so
many of us are still so reticent to discuss our sexuality let alone publicly disclose it. Yet one day I hope to come out of the closet.
And sometime afterwards - perhaps years or perhaps decades - I hope to
hear someone say:
A: "That's X. He's bisexual."
B: "Who the fuck cares."
My name is X. And I am a bisexual alpha male.
My name is X. And I am a bisexual alpha male.











34 comments:
Absolutely the best summation of the life and the choices I've ever read.
I lived the hetero choice for 24 years, fooled around 5, been in gay relationship 20. Couldn't go back if it was possible, but I still think of tits and pussy as often as cock and ass. The drive is slower after 65 but always sweet with someone who loves you. I got that now, why fuck it up?
I didn't read all of this because about halfway through I was pretty offended.
You ask that you not be judged for being bisexual, but there is a LOT of vitriol in this against gay men who cannot be straight-acting - you said so yourself that they can't help their nature, so why be so negative/condescending about it? That's being just as bad as anyone who judges YOU for being bisexual.
So you're going to tell me off based on an article that you didn't read in its entirety and perhaps got through the first quarter of?
Go fuck yourself, bro. Put on a dress while you're at it -- I'm sure it'll make you feel better about yourself.
I will agree that some of the article makes several assumptions and utilizes stereotypes of "flaming gay kids", and these can be offensive to some. You are a talented writer, but after reading only two of your articles I can make several assumptions also. I assume that you come from a family that is well off, either upper middle class or higher. That due to your good looks, much of life has been handed to you on some kind of precious metal platter, and most importantly, that the only major hardship that you've had to face in life is being bisexual. Life does not come that easily to most people. I am not trying to offend, and I do enjoy reading your articles. I am just stating that your style of writing can and will make you an easy target.
Yes, that's correct, because the first quarter of it reveals enough about your thought process that I don't need to read the rest of it. Are you familiar with the concept of cognitive dissonance?
Frat Star, you are as bigoted and closed-minded as any gay guy who insists that bi men don't exist. You are offensive. And your assertion that gay men are by and large "swishy" is wrong. And whatever you think about Brown U. and the like, at least these institutions don't perpetuate the kind of small-minded provincial stereotypical thinking that you obviously succumbed to long ago. Go away. And BLM, you just make yourself more of a loser for posting this crap.
Hey BLM, the fact that you still claim to be "bi" is ludicrous. You are just a chicken-shit gay man who can't admit it.
Frat Star needs to provide some backstory to how this manifesto came about, and what transpired afterwards.
He eventually came out as gay a few months ago and has been trying to find his way as a masculine gay guy. So while this manifesto gives you snapshot of his thoughts at one time, up til now, his references have been negative stereotypes of gays.
He is learning that the GLBT community is more diverse than he expected -- that there are the obvious "swishy/flaming" types but also many masculine acting guys like him. So cut him some slack.
Many of you when you first came out (if you even are out) had to deal with being swept up with all the negative stereotypes even though you yourself did not fit many of them. You then ended up being positive examples to others that we are more alike than different, and that helps our side gain society's acceptance.
Well gee whiz! Wasn't that revealing??? I haven't read or heard anything that deep or conceited since Barbara Walter's interview with Mike Tyson.
Hey X--alpha male. You ain't all that, I think it's time you come down off the mirrored pedestal you're on. Are you fuckin' serious, or are you just that stupid?
I tried to give you a fair shot last week, but you just blew it. I don't know who you think you're dealing with here, but we're not the pansy-assed, dress wearing sissies you take us for. As you say, "Fuck that!"
So Sterling, good luck. I don't know where you think you're going in life, or who you think you're talking to here. But you're in for a rude, crude awakening. You might think you're the hottest thing since your first mattress hump, but you're not. Fort Faggot here will cut you down to less than your last puny jizz wad you last shook of your grubby nail bitten finger.
Do yourself a favor. Call yourself Brat Star, and go sneak a blowie at the library.
Frat star -- Interesting expression of your thoughts & feelings about your sexual identity. I'm not joining the piling on here, because I think you're entitled to write down what's on your mind and share it for what it may be worth. You didn't ask anyone to subscribe to it, so for those who are "offended," too bad. I, for one, understand why you are terrified of being lumped in with the swishy set. They are not like you, and you are not like them.
Did you catch the contradiction in your piece - at one point you say that bisexuals are the "silent majority," but later you term them (us) an "oppressed minority." Of course you can't easily know which it is for the very reason that, as you say, most who feel this way are in the closet. In an Oxford Univ. study, the majority of the subjects (all college-age men) admitted that they were attracted to other men at least some of the time. So I think that the "silent majority" premise may be valid. It's just very difficult to tell, because as you say most of us will never admit how we feel in public for fear of the consequences.
Also, the "snowflake" metaphor is apt. The spectrum is no doubt immense, ranging from those whose interest in other men is limited to looking to those who are on Manhunt every day.
I think you're smart to keep your options open so that you can have a family if you want to. It's certainly worth some serious sacrifices. When you are 70, no one will care about you the way your own flesh and blood will (not that I'm 70 yet, but I can foresee what's coming). And if you haven't had children, when you're gone you are totally gone.
So, if I'm reading the objections correctly, Frat Star is the only one here who began his journey with negative stereotypes of what being gay is. The rest of us never had to dispose of our fear of being swishy, nelly, or queer...right? Give the guy a break. Where's all that sensitivity that is supposed to be your birth rite...or has it just become self centered defensiveness?
I don't see a talented writer. I see a pathetic self-loathing stereotype-inducing asshole! What I appreciated before this frat-fag douchebag came along was the real honesty in the writing but this hateful shit is disgusting! Another bog bites the dust for me if this is what's being touted as big news and good insightful writing.
Every now and then I used to check out Frat Star's other blog. I couldn't help come away with the feeling that in real life he must be nothing like this. It honestly sounds like he has created some cool character for himself to play online.
Then again, I don't know him from Adam, so maybe I'm offbase. And there are some good points hidden amongst the bro-tastic ridiculousness here.
To answer questions --
Rex V: Thanks, man. Much appreciated.
Anon @ 1:38: Perhaps. It's my writing style, I enjoy my shit, so... well there's little that I can do about it.
Anon @ 3:01: So now you're going to psychoanalyze me based off of a quarter of an article? You realize how nuts that is, right? Whatever though, it's your choice.
Anon @ 8:54: Yeah, let me do that real fast: I wrote this years ago when I was quite scared and didn't know what to do. This was just an analysis of my original position and I'm a different person now. We posted this based on requests to repost it since it disappeared with my old blog.
Bob: Seriously bro, stop drinking the haterade. Please dude, don't bother reading my blog in the future -- you can save yourself the trouble. Also, it's "fuck that noise" in its full form. Just FYI.
Shim: Self loathing? I am anything but self-loathing, my friend.
Anon @ 10:17: Nope, this is pretty much me.
I'll venture to say that most of us reading here are not the same people we were when we were closeted and confused. People change, mature, evolve, and so do their view points.
Settle down, sit back, and enjoy the show. But if you're truly offended, just stop reading.
Guys -- remember what it was like when you were in college -- young, brash, invincible, thought you knew everything because you had some education.
Frat Star will find out that there's lot of life he still needs to learn, especially about the diversity of the GLBT community. Many of us older guys had to struggle to accept ourselves, and if you are honest much of that was influenced by society's negative view of us.
So while we have the benefit of some hard learned lessons, Frat Star is just starting to accept himself, and trying to navigate how to fit in with other guys not carbon copies of himself. It may be uncomfortable at first, but if we support one another (instead of calling people names and attacking characters), we will be allies and stronger together.
OK. I will bother, only because you don't seem to understand. If you were in 7th grade, I could accept your approach a bit better, but I'm giving you the credit of being college age in 2012.
I doubt if you remember Andrew Dice Clay, but eventually he was publicly reduced to tears once he realized how much people hated his style, what he said. and how it affected his career. He now runs a gym according to Wikipedia. You parallel him. To be more current, you remind me of Mike "The Situation" Sorrentino from Jersey Shore; immense ego.
You don't seem to get that we're all on the same side here. You seem to discount that part of being bi, is what's part of being gay. Part of being gay, is part of accepting who you are.
Being bi for most people is all about being discreetly active, which is what you describe. We all get it that you want to remain in the closet, anyone here can respect that. That's OK. But when you turn around and bash someone who doesn't fit your profile, all in attempt to hide who and what you're a oart of is nothing but reprehensible. It's totally loathsome.
I can't excuse behavior like that, and I've never behaved that way toward anyone. For you to think that you can openly regard anyone with that type of attitude and receive no backlash is only naive on your part.
I was married for 19 years, and believe me, during that time, I knew all about what hiding and sneaking around was. I understand completely what it's like, and where you're coming from. However, now that I'm divorced, I've been out for the past 15 years. I'm totally out, to everyone, including work. I don't fit the general stereotype. People are surprised to learn that I'm gay, just as people are surprised to learn that you're bi. I don't jam being gay down people's throat. There's no gay flag on my car, no prancing around in leather or glitter, no lisp. Yet I have to admit, I'm part of all that. I have friends who do these things, and yet I'm not ashamed to be in their company. It's just that I don't find any of that to be my style. But you are so afraid, I don't think you could publicly do that. I don't think you could publicly appear with gay people; you're too much in the closet or denial. Along with your self obsessed image, it seems you're headed to a lifetime of conflict and hiding. Good luck with that. Good luck with having any kind of successful relationship with anyone, male or female.
I've known guys like you, one of them was a gym teacher at a public high school. He thought that he was pulling off his secret life, but the joke was on him. Eventually everyone knew, and eventually he was written off as a total phony. He's now a youngish 50 something retiree. He lives alone in a dumpy house along with his fantasies, and despite his visits to the gym, he's looking like a creepy old troll. No one's attracted to him, and it seems he has no friends. His ego caught up with him; that's where being in the closet and gay bashing got him.
Do you want to be that guy? Who's really drinking the haterade, and do you really think because of your age that you're exempt from reality? Remember, what goes around, comes around.
I love this guy. There is hope for us!
Okay, so let me get this right: some of you would be totally okay with this guy living in the closet, marrying some unsuspecting woman and ruining her life. Lying, cheating, fucking his kids up all in the name of some on the side but you have a problem with him saying mean things about gays?
Don't get me wrong, some of the guys here have been refresingly critical of the blogmaster and have made it clear what you think of his behaviour. But, this blog has a tremendous following. It would seem that more of you find the behavior acceptable. Oh, I guess only if you find the guy hot..otherwise all bets are off, huh?
This guy is a kid. Give him time. At least he's had the courage to admit who he his which is more than the esteemed owner of the blog has ever done. He moved though being "bi" to accepting he is gay without ruining his life and others in the process. For that he deserves more than feint praise.
I would suggest one look in the mirror before throwing around the "phoney" appellation. Until other people's feelings and wants and needs mean as much to you as your own, you will be just as phoney as that which you decry
Guys --
Stop, stop, stop. There's been a misunderstanding here of massive proportions.
I'm actually out. I've been out since early November of this year. I wrote this post approximately three years ago when I was pretty scared and alone. I later told this one girl, in confidence, about my issue. At the time, she was taking an ethics class at her school - a large, Catholic university - and they were discussing what it means to be "not straight" if you will. That was for her class, and I actually ended up getting an invitation from the Jesuit professor to do a Q&A. He was very much a gentleman and promised that my identity would be kept quiet and that he would moderate his students should someone say something rude.
That's the general purpose of the document you just read: to understand myself at the time and to educate others as to how I felt.
Therefore, this document is in the PAST. Not the PRESENT. This has been alluded to, but since most of you are quick to jump the gun, I feel that you haven't picked up on this pivotal fact.
Bob --
I wasn't even born when this "Andrew Dice Clay" or whatever his name is came about. I think it was during the late 80s? Yeah...
Thanks for telling me that I'm a loser based on what you've read on my blog. If you actually cared, which you claim to do, you'd probably read my posts at least a few times and, if you had done that, you'd know that the above is past not present. However, you do not and instead prefer to tell me that I'm a mix of a loser, something about mattress humping (?), etc. Also, thank you for the gym class teacher compliment. I can only hope to emulate such a glorious form of human being.
So long story short, you're still drinking the haterade.
Fuck you, Bob.
This confusion arose because BLM reposted without indicating that this is from the past, nor with any indication that you no longer support these beliefs.
Anon @ 2:20PM --
I understand that and there's very little I can do about that at this juncture. However, personally attacking me does not create a resolution to this problem.
However, since everyone has a huge problem it's worthwhile mentioning that they should have done their research before they presented an argument. BLM does say: "I asked Frat Star to re-publish a post he had written for his previous blog." In my article last week, I castigated those who chose to stay in the closet. I think my views are totally apparent. Those who complain seem to base their entire argument on different things each week -- they dislike me, perhaps because I'm new and they're resistant to change or because I'm cocky, but they don't actually have a basis for their criticism. It's just trolling.
The confusion over this post is understandable without any context to how it came about and what happened subsequently.
But instead of offering advice to someone obviously new and discovering himself, and with limited contact with the GLBT community, some of you have resorted to name calling and character attacks.
Calling Frat Star a bigot or offensive won't help him (or others who thought like him) without some explanation of why these statements are hurtful. If you are going to comment, at least make the responses constructive.
Have you ever heard of a disclaimer? Does it explain anywhere in this post: that was then and this is now?
If you're going to post anything, start from the present and explain how you may have had a turn around from things in the past. Don't push people with previous ramblings of self obsession. No where have you spoken to anyone else's feelings; everything's about your irresistible magnetism, as you see it.
You said you were a philosophy major; that doesn't show. You're also taking the stance as a poor defenseless college kid, alone and scared. Please, in today's world with a bravado like yours, do you really expect anyone to buy that? Do you really think an intelligent philosophy major would approach this entire dilemma the way you do?
Let's not forget that you've been out since November of this year; I guess you mean 2011. That's more or less 2 months. Do you really think anyone would entertain your life experience as valuable? Not that it's not valid, but it's hardly worthy of comparison.
Sorry, I can't side with you. I can't coddle your delicate youthful situation, your ego, your cause or your type. I just don't like guys like you; they evolve into nothing other than adult brats. Fuck me? No dude, fuck you.
Ok, I have been reading and e-mailing Frat-Star for almost a year now, and what you guys are saying isn't true.
I watched this kid struggle and fight, watched and read him cry, I watched him throw fits like a little kid--and then stand up like a man. If some of you had read his old blog you would know this.
Yo Frat--I got your back homie, fuck the haters man but also forgive them as well because they didn't follow and watch you grow as I and the other bros on your blog did. Give him a chance guys, he isn't that bad of a guy and he certainly isn't this parody that some of you have painted him as.
--GSR
3:10 AM,I think you have been the
most sane, and level headed of our
group that BLM has called ASSHOLES!!! I had neverr read Frat-Star, and I think that many of
BLM followers are in the same boat.
We didn't know what Frat-Star had evolved from. As I read I thought of our group as a bunch of bullies taunting our young generation of Gays. How are we no different than all the Bully's that populate our world. Maybe we should have
been given a look back and told,
what his life was, and is now 3 + years later. I think that we are no better than the accusers. I see
a lot of Love over in Justin Dunes
Blog, he will take you down if you
try any funny stuff. Peace to Frat-Star.
I have read Frat Star's previous blog and also this Manifesto (when it was originally posted) and continued to follow him and his JOURNEY (and life is nothing more than a journey) through that blog. He has grown in the 2+ years since I started reading it including posting his last post - which I hope BLM eventually posts (please make it sooner and not later...like next friday???) because it made me consider coming out little bi little to my family... Though I have not as of yet had the courage to do so I'm slowly inching toward there....FRAT STAR if nothing else ignore all of these negative comments and continue on your journey through life. Eventually I'll join you on the other side of the closet but for me its tiny steps out.
Oh man - all that ruckus here.
Even for me - an blog newbie - it was perfectly clear that this post was an older one. This guy had eveloped and formed new opinions. Where would the world be if that wasn't possible anymore?
And here comes what I think was the best explanation about sexuality I've ever read (I shortend it a bit, suitable for the board):
Imagine sexuality as a line. On one one end you have "Straight as an arrow". On the other hand you have who acknowlegde and embrace their love for other men. Guys who identify themselves as gay are on this end. And in reality everybody is on a different place on that line.
I like this explanation and I think people are not static at that line either.
So Frat Star - I like your posts and hope to read more.
I've taken the time to read all of these responses in full.
There is some pretty heavy philosophical concepts being spouted by those who excercise such original and creative criticism when they refer to frat as "self loathing", so on and so forth.
And why not?
It must certainly be true.
I too am delusional and a self loathing closeted gay man who secretly desires to wear womens clothing, snap my fingers and refer to my best friend as "girlfriend".
Hey listen fuckers,
don't tell anyone to "get over themselves",
GET OVER YOURSELVES.
I fully support your decision to be
the next contestants on rupauls drag race (yes, I have watched it),
but please, please, don't assume for a moment that every man who hates, with all his being, the silly steriotypical image of "gayness" ultimately hates himself.
Guys like us are angry because we noticed, from an early age, that our "straight buddies" may have been a little more interested in us, as we were in them, than sports and chasing girls allowed.
It was the strength of the steriotype-
that psychological black plague- that kept us apart and hooked into the safe, but bullshit mode of "either or sexuality". In other words, straight or gay.
Please get off this fuckin guys back. If you don't like what he writes, stop reading. It's still a free country.
And the openings for RuPauls side show are beckoning.
Forgive the caustic remarks, guys.
I guess we'll have to chalk my anger up my very well kept secret,
I am a drag queen in disguise.
Later,
Nick
Upon reading my posted comment, I realize I could have said more about myself.
I'm bi, but it's taken me years to realize that. Not because I lied to myself-
I knew I found guys, some guys,attractive both physically and emotionally. But I was convinced that the "one time rule"- the rule that states any attraction for another guy means that one is absolutely gay, ultimately applied to me as well.
So, closeted, confused and alone, I finally started going to a local gay bar after I had finally accepted that, YES, I too am gay and have to learn to deal with it.
So I did.
I was desperate for friendship.
I came out to an older gay neighbor and started hanging out with him at the local gay bar in order to become more "myself".
I hung out at the dump for close to a year, desperate to meet another guy, a buddy, someone I could become friends with, hang out with, do things with, and fool around with.
I did meet lots of guys and I'll tell you about a few of them.
The first was "floppy", a chubby cashier from publix fifteen years younger than me.
He liked to sit next to me, staring at me intensely while mouthing the words to the Lady Gaga songs quite animatedly as the music blared from the corner speakers.
Somehow, he felt it was impressive.
He was as tall as he was round and vaguely reminded me of the fat, Jewish chick from the "facts of life" sitcom.
I'm sure, in real life, he was a nice guy, though.
Then there was the "international drag queen", a middle eastern kid whose name escapes me. He ran a local gas station and had performed drag, once, in Mexico.
He liked to have dance contests with "floppy" and, when debating who won, he'd place his hand deliberately onto his side between his hip and upper body while pointing at floppy, yelling at him, screaming that HE was much "fiercer".
(Is that a word)?
"Piggy" was the DJ, a man in his thirties with breasts like a teenage girl and a penchant for performing oral sex in the boys bathroom at the end of the night.
His catch phrase was 'GO PHUCK YOURSELF", a statement he made to anyone and everyone without provocation and then laughed to himself for several minutes like the black English guy on the tanqueray commercial on TV, the guy with the space between his teeth and an annoying personality worse than that pig, Joan Rivers.
And yes, she's a pig.
She's not funny.
She's ugly, she's vulgar, she's classless and I'd be ashamed to call her my mother.
If you don't agree, tough shit.
The woman's a pig and so is Margret Chow.
I can describe the rest or the regulars at the bar, but I think you get the picture.
THEY WERE ALL THE SAME.
It was a gay heaven, a virtual dump that fullfilled every gay steriotype that straight guys make fun of and the directors of "Will and Grace" loaded onto the character of "Jack MCfarland".
And there I was, trying to fit in because ITS WHERE I BELIEVED I BELONGED. After all, "BI", was just an excuse to cover up my "gayness" and the fool that I was couldn't figure out why I began hating myself more than I did the clowns who filled the bar, weekend after weekend.
Let me tell you what guy's,
I don't blame straight dude's for their contempt of gay men, forgive me.
The anonymous sex, silly personalites, phony laughs, out of shape, chubby and effeminate clowns that I surrounded myself with bore all the trademark gay stigmas that I am convinced are affected and overblown womanly characteristics that were adopted in lieu of true masculinity.
Men, gay, straight, or like the majority of us- somewhere in between- can and should do without these phony traits IF they WISH TO BE RESPECTED BY SOCIETY. Not because society is owed anything but because PRIDE SHOULD BE THE RESULT OF PERSONAL ACHIEVEMENT, not the by product of a lifetime spent on gossip, cocktails, and an identity predicated on cock.
Absolutely the best summation of the life and the choices I've ever read.I think you have been the
most sane, and level headed of our
group that BLM has called ASSHOLES!!!Thanks......
Anon @ 7:20
Joan Rivers a pig? Shes a comedian ..you may not like her but I don't think anything she says or does can be taken as serious or even real. Anyway..you need to get a gmail name..become your writing, comments and insight are honestly to valuable to be lost as an anonymous poster.
I love this post! This is me! I'm bi..and I am and that's just how it's going to be. I can't change it...I'm not waiting or hiding from coming out as gay...I still like women...but men too. I just go back and forth between the two. I think Frat Star nailed everything on the head!
I love this post!.I think you have been the most sane, and level headed of our group that BLM has called ASSHOLES!Thanks..
Post a Comment